Dissertation Presentation
Transcript: The decline of geography in Bolton's primary schools and the role politics has in the decline. "64% of teaching was either satisfactory, unsatisfactory or poor, whilst only 36% was good. very good or excellent." (Catling et al, 2003) "in approximately one in ten primary schools visited , geography was more or less disappearing." (OFSTED, 2011) "More than 100 secondary schools do not enter a single pupil for a GCSE exam in the subject" (The Independent, 2011) "only some 50% of primary school teachers feel confident teaching geography." (Rawlinson, 2003) my observations are at risk of my bias "Both practical and classroom" "not seen as a main subject by other teachers." Observation Joseph McQuaid Qualitative St John's Q) Do you enjoy doing geography? A) "We don't really do geography." Study Area What are children's perceptions of geography in their schools? Do they enjoy it? Geography is still there, but only through the use of 'topics'. 'Topics' include geography, history, art and others !? "Closure of several University geography departments, the decline in number of geography students wishing to enter teaching and a diminishing of the subjects status in English schools" (Rawlinson, 2003) Thank You Geography is no longer seen as a main subject in the National Curriculum in Bede Burn Primary school (cc) photo by jimmyharris on Flickr teachers may not be totally honest Students feel like they do not study geography, and teachers feel they are teaching geography when teaching the topic (geography of the olympics). St Teresa's St John's the Evangelist St Columba's OFSTED, (2011), Geography declining in schools, NR2011-04, Manchester [OFSTED]. OFSTED, (2008), Geography in schools – changing practice, 070044, Manchester [OFSTED]. OFSTED, (2011), Report Summary, Geography, learning to make a world of difference, 090224, Manchester [OFSTED]. political side of the research government spending on education and OFSTED reports new curriculum? qualitative St Columba's Teacher's lessons are "not good enough in half of schools." (Telegraph, 2011) Adey, K., Biddulph, M., (2001) 'The Influence of Pupil Perceptions on Subject Choice at 14+ in Geography and History', Educational Studies, 27: 4, 439 — 450 BBC, (2011), Geography declining in many English schools – OFSTED [Online], available: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-12359446 [27/02/2011]. Boyle, Bill and Bragg, Joanna(2006) 'A curriculum without foundation', British Educational Research Journal, 32: 4, 569 — 582 Butt, Graham , Weeden, Paul , Chubb, Steven and Srokosz, Anne(2006) 'The State of Geography Education in English Secondary Schools: An Insight into Practice and Performance in Assessment', International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 15: 2, 134 — 148 Castree, N., Fuller, D., Lambert, D., (2007), ‘Geography without borders’, Boundary crossings, 31, 129 – 132. No specialism (cc) photo by Metro Centric on Flickr limitations Indepth interviews Students not even sure what geography is!? Asking individual children at Bede Burn: Brainstorm research questions "I'm trying to bring geography into my class everyday." Quantitative & Qualitative (cc) photo by Metro Centric on Flickr Observations Q) What do you learn in geography? A) "What, like places? We're doing about pharaohs in Egypt at the moment." References Geography and History taught together Taught as topic: Egypt, Olympics Not aware of geography lesson If Children don't realise they are doing Geography they will never develop a love for the subject. problem? Questions to pupils every teacher in each school = 6 teachers per school Conclusion Government are very irrational methodology Results Rawlinson, S., Essex-Cater, L., Bolden, D., and Constable, H., (2003) 'Have Geographers Lost Their Way? Issues relating to the recruitment of geographers into school teaching', Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 27: 1, 39 — 56 Rose, J., (2009), ‘Independent review of the Primary Curriculum: Final Report’. Stannard, K., (2003), ‘Earth to academia: on the need to reconnect university and school geography’, Area, 35.3, 316 – 322. The Telegraph, (2011), Geography lessons ‘not good enough in half of schools’ [Online], available: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/8301240/Geography-lessons-not-good-enough-in-half-of-schools.html [27/02/2011]. The Telegraph, (2011), without geography, the world would be a mystery to us [online], available: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/8301966/Without-geography-the-world-would-be-a-mystery-to-us.html [27/02/2011]. literature review St Teresa's Primary Geography? So far ... Is the decline of geography significant in primary schools today? Q) Top 5 subjects? A) "Literacy, Science, PE, Art, Maths." Rachael Locker's bum stinks (cc) photo by Franco Folini on Flickr Ask students how they feel about geography in their schools using sticky notes to involve students words or pictures Geography graduate teacher Interview with geography graduate teacher, St